| Food-contact compliance |
20% |
Product-specific declarations, test reports, material specifications, and the intended-use conditions covered by the documentation. |
Check that evidence relates to the finished plate and applicable destination-market rules. For example, U.S. requirements may include relevant provisions of 21 CFR 176.170; EU food-contact materials are governed by Regulation (EC) No 1935/2004 and applicable specific measures. |
Documentation is current, traceable to the product, and covers the plate’s actual food type, contact time, and temperature. |
| Product performance and consistency |
15% |
Technical data sheet, samples, dimensional tolerances, grammage or basis-weight specification, and agreed inspection criteria. |
Test samples with the intended foods and serving conditions; assess rigidity, leakage or grease resistance where relevant, rim integrity, and batch-to-batch variation. |
Samples meet written acceptance criteria and production batches are checked against the same specifications. |
| Quality-management controls |
15% |
Quality manual or process summary, inspection records, nonconformance and corrective-action procedures, and relevant third-party audit certificates if available. |
Review whether controls cover incoming materials, in-process checks, finished-product release, complaints, and change management. Verify certificate scope and validity rather than relying on a certificate alone. |
Defined inspection responsibilities, retained records, and documented corrective actions are available for review. |
| Production capacity and resilience |
10% |
Capacity by plate size and specification, current utilization, production-site details, contingency arrangements, and a written supply plan. |
Compare stated capacity with forecast demand and confirm whether capacity is dedicated, shared, or dependent on subcontractors. Validate lead-time assumptions through a trial order. |
The supplier provides a credible capacity plan and explains how disruptions or demand changes are managed. |
| Material sourcing and traceability |
10% |
Material declarations, supplier-lot records, product batch codes, and documented procedures for tracing and withdrawing affected goods. |
Conduct a sample traceability exercise from finished plate batch to input materials and production records; ask how long records are retained. |
A defined lot identification system supports timely forward and backward traceability. |
| Environmental claims and end-of-life fit |
10% |
Evidence for fiber sourcing or recycled content claims, coating and additive details, and any applicable compostability or recyclability test reports. |
Check that claims apply to the complete plate, including coatings, inks, and adhesives, and match the disposal infrastructure and rules in the sales market. Compostability standards such as EN 13432 or ASTM D6868 may be relevant to certain packaging configurations; confirm product scope and certification details. |
Environmental claims are specific, substantiated, and do not imply that all paper plates are recyclable or compostable in every location. |
| Delivery and export readiness |
8% |
Written lead times, order and shipping records where available, packaging details, export documents, and agreed delivery terms. |
Compare quoted lead times with actual trial-order performance. Confirm shipment protection, carton labeling, palletization, and responsibility for freight and customs tasks. |
Commitments are clearly documented and delivery performance can be measured against agreed dates. |
| Customization and specification control |
5% |
Available diameters, shapes, embossing or printing options, artwork process, tooling requirements, and written change-control procedures. |
Confirm that the supplier can reproduce approved samples and obtain approval before changing materials, production sites, or critical specifications. |
Customization options, approval steps, and any tooling or setup charges are disclosed in advance. |
| Commercial transparency |
4% |
Itemized quotation, minimum order quantity, payment terms, price validity, packaging costs, and stated assumptions behind the offer. |
Compare like-for-like specifications and landed-cost components; ask how price changes are communicated and handled. |
The quotation clearly identifies included services, exclusions, and conditions that could affect the final price. |
| Communication and issue resolution |
3% |
Named contact roles, response process, complaint procedure, and examples of corrective-action documentation with confidential details removed. |
Track response clarity and timeliness during sample approval and trial-order stages; confirm escalation and complaint-handling steps. |
Questions receive clear answers, and product or delivery issues have a documented route to resolution. |
| Total suggested weighting |
100% |
Score each criterion using the same evidence-based scale, and treat legal or food-safety requirements as pass/fail gates where appropriate. |